Saturday, November 21, 2026

Optio as a solitaire game

Above: the Carthaginian heavy chariots charge the Syracusan Medium Cavalry. It was at this point in the battle that the Carthaginians began to have warm fuzzy feelings.

Since Ancients wargamers won't all agree to move to London and find face-to-face opponents whenever they need them, solitaire play continues to be a thing. Which made me wonder: how does Optio pan out as a solitaire game? Since I have a regular gaming partner I haven't had to resort much to solitaire play but, heck, time to see how it works.

I used the same armies as for the Sicilian campaign game (second battle next week as I couldn't make it to Peter's this weekend), namely:

Carthage

  • 2 x Carthaginian Medium cavalry
  • 2 x Numidian Light Horse
  • 2 x Chariots
  • 2 x elite Poeni foot
  • 4 x average Poeni foot
  • 6 x Allied Hoplites
  • 6 x Mercenary Scutarii Auxilia
  • 4 x Mercenary Balearic Slingers
  • 2 x Numidian Skirmisher foot
  • 2 x Allied Greek Psiloi

Syracuse

  •  2 x Syracusan Medium Cavalry
  • 2 x Greek Light Horse
  • 2 x Syracusan elite Epilektoi Hoplites
  • 6 x Syracusan Citizen Hoplites
  • 6 x Allied Hoplites 
  • 4 x Allied Peltasts
  • 2 x Mercenary Gallic Warband
  • 4 x Allied Slingers
  • 4 x Allied Psiloi

I used the VASSAL Optio module for this game. I made up the terrain, giving both sides pretty equal chances. The Syracusan general had a command rating of 3 and a combat rating of 3 whilst the Carthaginian general had a command rating of 4 and a combat rating of 3. This obliged the Syracusans to begin deployment by putting down 1/3 of their army followed by 1/3 of the Carthaginians and so on.

The Balearic Slingers outrange Syracuse's slingers and have better morale as do the Numidian Light Foot compared to the Greek Psiloi. Carthage has those fearsome chariots but Syracuse does have more heavy infantry, and their peltasts can handle the Scutarii provided they stick to the woods. I really couldn't see a decisive advantage for either side. Both armies have 4 commands, indicated by the coloured rectangles around the morale scales.

For the battle report I reproduce my thinking for each side as the game progressed. I wasn't particularly rooting for either side so tried to be as objective as possible: see the problems and opportunities both sides encounter and act accordingly. 

BTW as a counsel of perfection it's best to view this battle report on a PC - you really need a big screen to make out all the details. Incidentally the "Destroyed Stands" section on the right was used to accommodate routed stands as I did not leave routed units on the battlefield (which can be subsequently slaughtered for a greater victory score).

Since Syracuse deployed first it moves first. My plan for the Syracusans is to advance the phalanx then slide to its right and line up with the wood to stop the chariots. Hoplites can deal with chariots. That will also allow the Syracusan MC under the command of the general to nip over to the Syracusan left and help the LH there. Chariots are unwieldy so difficult to point in a new direction (if they turn 90 degrees they become disordered; if they form a column they become disordered, and it takes them 4 turns to restore order, making them useless for a large part of the battle).

The peltasts advance in the woods. Their job is to keep the Scutarii occupied. 

The LH hang back for now. Their commander is superior to the Carthaginian LH commander so they will commit when the time is right, i.e. when the situation becomes clear on the other flank.

The Carthaginians don't have a clear plan yet, other than to await developments. The infantry advance, allowing the Balearic Slingers to outrange their opposite numbers in the Syracusan line. Let's see what the Syracusans do. It is possible to switch the MC over to the other wing if necessary.

The Syracusan decide to advance so as the bring the enemy into range of their Slingers. The Syracusans have fewer light troops than the Carthaginians which is something to worry about, but not a deal breaker. Keep in mind that LI unit in a thin line of LI (one stand only) can shoot enemy LI only during the enemy's move, i.e. once per turn and not twice.

The LH also advance, ostensibly keeping pace as a flank guard for the infantry but in fact getting ready to charge the Carthaginian LH.

Realising their advantage in light troops, the Carthaginians advance the infantry line, bring all LI missile troops into play. Meantime the mounted troops hang back, waiting to see what the Syracusans do.

The Syracusans pause, content to let the missile exchange continue whilst looking for an advantage. The LH continue to advance. It will be thrown against its opposite number before long.

The Carthaginians also wait. They have the advantage in missile power so are content to let the LI exchange continue.

Syracuse, realising that doing nothing can only help the Carthaginians, decides to commit its LH.

The Carthaginian LH use delaying tactics against the Syracusan LH. Meanwhile the Carthaginian heavy infantry advance whilst their LI retire through them. This is done out of concern for the Carthaginian right flank, which risks becoming exposed if its LH are neutralised. Best to force the HI fight now.

On consideration this was probably a mistake. 

Syracuse decides to use its numerically superior infantry by engaging the Carthaginian HI with all of its best units, which means betting the Epilektoi into the fight via a diagonal move. The LI retire through the files and everyone readies for the main engagement.

Meanwhile the Syracusan LH gets around to the rear of the Carthaginian LH and donates some javelins to the Carthaginian pincushion fund. 

Carthage decides to wait. Whoever crosses the stream to attack will be at a disadvantage. Meanwhile the general moves from the MC to the Chariots (shown in next image). The plan is to use the Chariots to charge the Syracusan MC and force a crisis on their right flank.

Syracuse also decides to wait whilst its LH charge the Carthaginian LH. Meantime the Syracusan general takes personal command of the Epilektoi hoplites and the entire phalanx. The general has a better combat rating than the Carthaginian commander with the Carthaginian elite infantry, so will at least win the charge combat.

The Carthaginian Chariots move up to the stream, ready for the charge, leaving the MC trailing behind them. The LI of both sides, now out of command, advance by half-square moves to try and get into a better position to come to grips with the enemy.

Here the Syracusans commit a cardinal mistake. Worried about their right flank they decide to precipitate the infantry fight, and charge across the stream. The plan is for the Epilektoi to outfight the Carthaginian elite hoplites on their right flank whilst their Warband outflank and roll up the Carthaginian line on their left. This hopefully will be enough to counter losing the fight in the centre. The Syracusan elite hoplites win the charge thanks to their superior general, but elsewhere the fight is drawn.

Meantime the Syracusan LH finally charge the Carthaginan LH. In the fierce fight both commanders are wounded! 

The Chariots charge and the Syracusan MC evade. This brings the Chariots into range of the Syracusan Psiloi who waste no time.

The Carthaginian LH rout. First blood to Syracuse.

The victorious Syracusan LH occupy the vacated square.

Syracuse advances the Warband on its left towards the Carthaginian flank. Being out of command (the rest of its battleline is in contact with the enemy) it moves only 1/2 a square per turn, so this is going to take some time. 

The LH forms column and also prepares to move to the Carthaginian flank. Whoever gets there first.... 

Chaaarge! The Carthaginian chariots hit the Syracusan MC with devastating force. With no room to evade the MC have to take it on the nose. They survive, for now. Actually I forgot that mounted vs mounted charge combat is resolved twice, which would have routed the MC on the spot. Oh well, they'll route in the melee so it all comes out in the wash.

...and the MC rout in the melee. Elsewhere the lines hold.

The Chariots occupy the square vacated by the fleeing MC.

The Syracusans head for the Carthaginian right flank at full speed. Some LI move to the left to deal with the Chariots.

The Carthaginian Chariots and MC surround the Syracusan Epilektoi Hoplites. Bring them down!

Disorder is at least partially remedied.

The stream bonus finally benefits the Carthaginians, giving their heavy infantry a high white modifier which enables their highest white interval to fight as firm, winning the melee against the shaken Syracusans.

A Psiloi unit moves across, clearing the way for the Syracusan Slingers to chuck stones at the Chariots. Rout them, fast! Not a rout just yet but the Chariots' morale is dropped to the lowest interval, preventing them from charging the Hoplites. Job well done, lads!

Meantime the LH charge the Carthaginian allied Hoplites in the flank, disordering them. The fighting is proving furious on both flanks. 

The Carthaginian MC slam into the flank of the Epilektoi Hoplites, disordering them. The Chariots meantime move away, trying to escape the hail of javelins and pellets. On the other flank the Balearic Slingers are also giving a mounted unit a hard time, pelting the Syracusan MC, whilst Infantry Skirmishers pelt the Warband.

Order is improved for disordered units.

The Syracusan centre collapses. The route of a Carthaginian allied Hoplite unit on the right is cold comfort.

The victorious Carthaginian infantry advance.

Cold comfort turns into tepid comfort when the Syracusan Slingers shoot the Chariots to rout. One must count one's blessings.... Meanwhile the Syracusan allied Hoplite units charge on their left, trapping one Balearic Slinger unit and forcing a LI unit to evade.

Carthaginian Hoplite units turn to confront the Syracusans on their flanks. Time for mopping up.

Units gradually sort themselves out.

Down go the Balearic Slingers. No big deal as they don't count for loss points.

Advancing against fleeing enemy at least feels good.

The Syracusan LH charge Carthaginian allied Hoplites in the flank, disordering them.

Carthaginian allied Hoplites charge Syracusan Hoplites in turn, whilst a LI unit moves up to screen the MC.

"Straight ranks and files, you 'orrible little men!"

The Syracusan Epilektoi and the last allied Hoplite units go down. At this point it's all over for Syracuse bar the shouting.

Punic power prevails! Syracuse is now one loss point from complete rout.

To rub salt in the wounds, down goes a Syracusan Psiloi unit. Nothing for it but to try and reconstitute the line on the right and attempt to accomplish something.

Carthage moves towards the right. They will finish the battle there.

Units continue to shuffle into order.

The Syracusan LH pull back before melee (they would have pulled back in the Syracusan move but I forgot to note it). So no melee this turn.

In go the Syracusan LH, trying to bring down the disordered Hoplites.

Carthaginian infantry and cavalry move at top speed towards the right. Time to end this. The Warband get shot at from front and back.

Order restored....

What to do, what to do? Nothing left for Syracuse except to hammer away at those Hoplites.

And then it's all over. The Carthaginian LI finally shoot the Warband to rout. Two more loss points and all average Carthaginian units automatically rout. The resolute units are already gone, so that's the entire army taking early military retirement. Game over!

So how did Syracuse lose? The big mistake was to allow Carthage to have the stream defense bonus. The Syracusans would have done better to hang back, keeping to the hill with its own defense bonus and letting the Carthaginians come to them. Carthage would have had the option of either driving against the Syracusans or calling off the battle (= a draw). Next time....

As a solitaire game Optio worked very well. The system works on implementing sound general tactical principles then seizing opportunities as they arise. It isn't like chess. There are far too many options in each turn to calculate more than about a move ahead. You can do some calculating but you are continually surprised by a constantly evolving tactical situation. I found it great fun. Will definitely do it again some time soon.